Many consumers are familiar with the frustration of trying to switch to a cheaper electricity provider, only to find the cancellation process on a website designed like a labyrinth. Once you finally locate the correct section, you are often hit by increasingly desperate "Don't Leave!" promotions. Eventually, many users simply give up and decide it is easier to stay put for another year. These tactics have been common practice for businesses in Germany, but the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has now issued a new ruling to stamp out such tricks designed to keep customers locked into contracts.
The legal challenge was brought by the national consumer rights group Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband (VBZ) against the gym chain FitX. The VBZ argued that the FitX website failed to meet legal requirements to make contract cancellation intuitive and easy for users. On July 16th, the Federal Court of Justice agreed, ruling that contract cancellation pages must lead directly to the cancellation process. Though the ruling was prompted by FitX, it applies to all manner of online contract providers, including streaming services, newspapers, energy, and telecommunications. Loans, insurance, and other financial services are exempt from this ruling.
The VBZ described the decision as a milestone for consumer protection rights in Germany. VBZ executive director Ramona Pop stated, "It makes it clear that anyone who clicks the cancellation button must actually be able to cancel – without distractions, without detours, without tricks." Pop added that companies must not use the confirmation page to try to dissuade people from canceling, noting that the cancellation button was created as a clear, reliable way to opt out of online contracts.
Under the new rules, companies may still ask for information needed to identify the contract, such as a full name, email address, home address, or contract number. Once these details are provided, a visible and clearly labeled button must trigger the cancellation. According to Section 312k of the Civil Code, the button and the confirmation page must be permanently available and easily accessible. Consumers should look for a button that says "Jetzt kündigen" (Cancel now) to submit their request. If such a button cannot be found, users should send an email to customer service with their full details and a brief notice of cancellation. A recommended phrase is, "Hiermit kündige ich meinen Vertrag fristgerecht zum nächstmöglichen Zeitpunkt," which means "I hereby cancel my contract at the earliest possible deadline."
Consumers should not feel pressured into making a phone call to cancel, as an online process should be sufficient for most small contracts like gym memberships or streaming services. Once a request is submitted online, providers must confirm the termination immediately. Consumers are advised to save any confirmation received and note the contract end date. If providers fail to follow the law, any deadlines for terminating the contract may be lifted. Those in need of further support should contact their local consumer protection group.
Ahead of the deadline, you log on to your account and search for a way to cancel your contract. It turns out, however, that the website is designed like a labyrinth and it's nearly impossible to find what you're looking for.
READ ALSO: How long do you need to keep receipts and invoices for in Germany?
