Josh Allen Faces Backlash After Multiple Super Bowl Prediction

Published: July 18, 2026, 8:40 pm

The potential for Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen to secure a Super Bowl title has become a persistent topic of debate in the NFL. During an appearance on 'The Dan Patrick Show' this past Thursday, former Dallas Cowboys head coach Jason Garrett offered a bold forecast, suggesting that Allen is on a trajectory to eventually win multiple Super Bowls.

Garrett defended his stance by drawing parallels between Allen’s current career path and those of NFL legends John Elway and Peyton Manning. He noted that both Hall of Fame quarterbacks faced similar skepticism regarding their ability to succeed in the postseason before eventually breaking through to win championships. According to Garrett, Allen is currently "knocking on the door" and will inevitably achieve that championship success.

However, the prediction was met with immediate pushback. Podcast host Dan Patrick expressed doubt regarding Allen’s postseason résumé, bluntly labeling him a "regular season quarterback." The criticism continued on social media, where former Kansas City Chiefs offensive guard Geoff Schwartz publicly mocked the projection. In a post on X, Schwartz questioned the premise of the argument, stating, "Can he play in one before he’s going to win multiple Super Bowls?"

Allen’s statistical record remains a focal point in these discussions. Throughout his eight-season NFL career, he has accumulated over 30,000 passing yards and more than 220 touchdown passes. During the 2024 season, he started all 17 games, leading the Bills to a 12-5 record while throwing for 3,668 yards and 25 touchdowns with a 69.3% completion rate. Despite these regular-season achievements, his playoff performance remains a subject of scrutiny; across 15 postseason appearances, Allen holds an 8-7 record, having recorded 3,915 passing yards, 29 touchdowns, and a 66.5% completion rate.

Photo: Collected