A Florida mechanic and tow truck driver, Dwain Hall, has been convicted of the first-degree murder and kidnapping of 32-year-old British music teacher Sonia Exelby. The verdict follows a trial where jurors examined extensive evidence, including phone records, email logs, and social media activity, which traced the victim’s movements after she traveled from her home in Portsmouth, England, to meet Hall in the United States.
Prosecutors detailed how Hall had groomed Exelby on a fetish website before convincing her to fly to Florida in October 2025. Upon her arrival, authorities say Hall picked her up from the Gainesville airport and transported her to an Airbnb rental. Investigators later discovered evidence at the property linking Hall to her disappearance and death, including video footage of Exelby on his cellphone and records of transactions made on her bank cards.
During the proceedings, prosecutors argued that Hall was aware of Exelby’s history of mental illness and suicidal ideation, and that he deliberately exploited these vulnerabilities to bring her to Florida. The prosecution alleged that Exelby had previously posted online about wanting someone to end her life, and that Hall targeted her for his own sadistic pleasure. Prosecutor Amy Beth Berndt described the victim as a kind, deeply loved woman who should still be alive today, characterizing Hall as an "Alpha Sadist" who took advantage of a woman incapable of making rational decisions.
The defense, represented by attorney Junior Barrett, maintained that Exelby had traveled to the United States with the intention of taking her own life. In his closing statement, Barrett argued that the victim felt worthless and viewed herself as a burden to others. He contended that the case should not be decided based on a dislike for Hall’s lifestyle or the adult content he consumed, asserting that the fact Hall did not stop her from killing herself did not constitute murder.
Following the delivery of the guilty verdict, the victim’s brother, Barry Wilton, spoke about the devastating impact of the loss on his family. Addressing Hall directly, Wilton stated, "You pretended to care for Sonia. You didn’t at all. You used her to fulfil your sick fantasies. You had her life in your hands. You had the opportunity to save her, but instead you preyed on her vulnerabilities and you took her from us."





