On November 19, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague, Netherlands, is scheduled to deliver its judgment in the case of The Gambia v. Myanmar. The proceedings concern allegations that Myanmar violated the 1948 Genocide Convention during its campaign against the Rohingya. For the Rohingya community, this moment represents the culmination of decades of persecution and nearly 10 years of waiting for accountability. While a legal judgment cannot restore a murdered child to a mother or recover years stolen from a generation, the community maintains that recognition and the act of being heard are fundamentally important.
The author, who was present at the ICJ for the case's opening session in 2019, notes that as the judgment approaches, the discourse is increasingly shifting away from the victims whose lives are directly at stake. In September, a Wall Street Journal opinion piece authored by Orde F. Kittrie and Andres B. Munoz-Mosquera warned that the ICJ might lower the legal threshold for genocide, citing potential implications for South Africa’s case against Israel and future claims against the United States and NATO members. The piece further suggested that the Trump administration could potentially sanction judges who voted to lower that threshold. In October, U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. Mike Waltz amplified this argument by invoking Washington’s previous sanctions against the International Criminal Court, raising questions about the independence of international justice when powerful states threaten consequences for judicial interpretations they find inconvenient.
Professor Michael Becker, a former ICJ legal officer, recently explained that the Court’s treatment of genocidal intent could have repercussions for South Africa’s case. While this is a legitimate legal discussion, the possibility that a judgment on the Rohingya could affect another state is not a valid reason to politically contain the case. Professor John Packer of the University of Ottawa has emphasized that there is no separate or adjustable genocide threshold to be lowered based on whose interests are affected. The law is the Genocide Convention, and the central question remains whether the evidence satisfies it. The law cannot be universal in principle but selectively protected in practice.
Beyond the legal debate, the Rohingya remain in a dire humanitarian situation. Human Rights Watch’s 2017 report, "All of My Body Was Pain," documented the experiences of 52 Rohingya women and girls, including 29 survivors of rape. These accounts detailed sexual violence committed alongside killings, the destruction of villages, and forced displacement. These women carried their trauma across the Naf River into refugee camps, where they continue to live without adequate healthcare, justice, or the security of knowing they will not be forced to flee again. The world has become comfortable discussing the Rohingya as a legal question, a humanitarian issue, or a diplomatic inconvenience, yet there are human beings behind every one of these descriptions.
Some legal commentators view The Gambia v. Myanmar as a stepping stone for other proceedings. However, for the Rohingya, this is their case—the product of years of organizing, survivor testimony, and advocacy. The community did not spend decades fighting erasure so that their suffering could become a footnote in another party's legal argument. The Rohingya deserve justice in their own right, rather than having their suffering deemed worthy of attention only when it proves useful to another cause.
Whatever the Court decides on November 19, the struggle will not end. A finding against Myanmar would be a historic step, but it would not return the Rohingya home, restore their citizenship, recognize their identity, or dismantle the systems that made genocide possible. That requires sustained international pressure and a credible process of transitional justice. Conversely, if the Court does not find Myanmar responsible, that judgment will not erase documented atrocities, invalidate survivor testimony, or end the pursuit of justice. The community is not waiting passively; Rohingya-led universal jurisdiction initiatives, such as the genocide case in Indonesia—where the author is a lead complainant represented by Themis Indonesia and supported by the Myanmar Accountability Project—show that alternative pathways to justice are being built. Ultimately, the judges must be allowed to assess the evidence and apply the law without the pressure of political intimidation or geopolitical anxieties.
You have reached the limit of 3 free articles this month.



