A significant diplomatic controversy has erupted within the European Union after several member states called for Spain to be blocked from the bloc's visa-free Schengen travel zone. The demands follow a chaotic week at the Spanish enclave of Ceuta in Morocco, where authorities reported that 60,000 migrants arrived, though Spanish officials later confirmed that 20,000 of those individuals have since returned to Morocco.
The Schengen zone, one of the European Union's most tangible achievements, is a vast border-free travel area where checks have been abolished for travelers. Developed gradually since 1985, the system saw border checks effectively removed in 1995 between Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Spain, and Portugal.
Today, the zone encompasses 29 countries, including most EU members—with the notable exceptions of Cyprus and Ireland—alongside Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway, and Switzerland. Within this area, both EU citizens and nationals of non-EU countries can travel freely without being subject to standard border checks.
The recent calls for suspension were spearheaded by Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, who on Thursday described the images of the migrant arrivals in Ceuta as "shocking" and suggested that Spain should be suspended from the Schengen area. Spain reacted sharply to the proposal, blasting Italy's stance as "demagoguery" and summoning the Italian ambassador to Madrid to lodge a formal protest.
By Friday, the pressure on Spain grew as Finland backed Italy’s call, and Denmark indicated that the EU should consider such a move.
Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen stated that it goes without saying that the EU must immediately take all necessary measures and consider all options, including a suspension of Schengen cooperation. Finnish Interior Minister Mari Rantanen added that countries failing to fulfill their obligation to protect the external border cannot be members of the Schengen zone.
Despite these political demands, legal experts and European texts suggest such an action is not possible. Marie-Laure Basilien-Gainche, a law professor at Lyon 3 University, explained that there is no provision in the Schengen framework for this kind of action, noting that one state cannot unilaterally expel another from the area.
While expulsion is not an option, the Schengen code does allow member states to temporarily reinstate border checks under exceptional circumstances, such as a serious threat to internal security or public order, including terrorism, organized crime, or public health emergencies like the Covid pandemic.
Controls can also be reintroduced if there are sudden, large-scale unauthorized movements of third-country nationals. Following the events, France tightened checks on its border with Spain, though Professor Basilien-Gainche noted that there is no shared internal border between Italy and Spain, nor between Spain and Finland.
The European Union has officially rejected the calls to suspend Spain. A European official, speaking on the condition of anonymity, stated that while the EU understands that some governments are concerned, the priority remains securing external borders. Brussels also noted that the current crisis is localized to the enclave of Ceuta on the African continent, and no movement has been detected toward mainland Europe.
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen described the scenes in Ceuta as "unacceptable," and her executive team remains in contact with both Spain and Morocco to address the situation.
READ ALSO: What problems lie ahead for Europe's border-free Schengen zone?
