Former U.S. Ambassador to China and NATO Nicholas Burns has raised strong concerns regarding President Donald Trump's scheduled trilateral meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, labeling the decision to exclude key allies like Ukraine and Japan a critical error for American foreign policy.
Burns, who served as the Biden administration's ambassador to China and as U.S. ambassador to NATO under President George W. Bush, cautioned that the exclusive gathering in Shenzhen, China, sends a alarming message to key American partners across Europe and Asia. Now an international relations scholar at Harvard University, Burns pointed out that core U.S. allies including Japan, South Korea, the Philippines, and NATO member states are deeply anxious about the upcoming meeting.
A central criticism highlighted by Burns is the inclusion of the war in Ukraine on the summit agenda without Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy present in the room. He emphasized that allowing three world powers to negotiate or potentially decide the future of Ukraine over the heads of its leadership is a major failure of U.S. diplomacy, stressing that the fate of a sovereign nation should not be deliberated without its direct participation during this decade.
Drawings parallels to history, Burns noted that the trilateral format mirrors the February 1945 Yalta Conference, where Joseph Stalin, Franklin D. Roosevelt, and Winston Churchill determined the structure of Eastern Europe without the involvement of Eastern European nations. Although acknowledging clear historical differences 81 years later, he warned that having three dominant global powers debate Ukraine's outcome—where Putin acts as the aggressor and Zelenskyy as the victim—poses a severe threat to U.S. credibility within the NATO alliance and directly damages trust with the Ukrainian people.
Burns also highlighted the glaring absence of Japan from the diplomatic table, identifying Tokyo as the primary U.S. ally in Asia. Over the past year, both China and Russia have conducted a joint campaign of intimidation against Japan, incorporating economic boycotts alongside coordinated Russian and Chinese military maneuvers around the Japanese home islands. He argued that prioritizing a high-profile photo opportunity with non-allied powers over the interests of steadfast partners undermines the strategic value of U.S. alliance networks.
Beyond territorial conflicts, the summit takes place against a backdrop of intensifying technological friction between Washington and Beijing. Amid allegations of Chinese espionage targeting advanced artificial intelligence technologies from Nvidia, Burns noted that neither President Trump nor President Xi is expected to bring up chip spying directly during their main session. However, high-level diplomatic contacts are set to occur in Shenzhen to address Chinese efforts to illicitly acquire American semiconductors for AI advancement.
Addressing recent enforcement actions, Burns commended the decision by the U.S. Justice and Commerce Departments to shut down access to Chinese shell companies operating in Southeast Asia that funnel restricted microchips into mainland China. While praising the move, he criticized the timeline, stating that the regulatory crackdown was long overdue and should have been executed a year earlier. In response to the U.S. sanctions, a spokesperson for China's Foreign Ministry signaled that Beijing could implement retaliatory countermeasures. Burns warned that despite President Xi personally greeting President Trump upon his arrival at the Shenzhen airport, underlying tensions could ignite a localized trade dispute as China routinely responds to U.S. economic restrictions.
On the issue of strategic security, Burns backed President Trump's intention to bring up nuclear non-proliferation, even though Beijing remains reluctant to negotiate. China is currently undertaking the largest and most non-transparent expansion of its nuclear arsenal in global history. Having personally raised the concern during his diplomatic tenure in Beijing without success, Burns warned that joint Chinese and Russian strategic nuclear arsenals are projected to outnumber and outweigh the U.S. nuclear stockpile in the 2030s, marking an unprecedented shift since the start of the nuclear arms race. He urged Washington and its allies in NATO and Japan to maintain pressure on Beijing for greater transparency, despite expecting little immediate concession from President Xi during the summit.
NICHOLAS BURNS: Good morning, Leila. Thank you.
FADEL: When you say it's a major mistake, what would the consequences of that mistake be?




