French Moderates Face Calls to Hold Primary Against Le Pen

Published: November 20, 2026, 7:01 am

Calls are growing across France to organize a single primary among moderate and mainstream politicians to take on far-right frontrunner Marine Le Pen in the upcoming presidential election. Ahead of the contest scheduled for April and May 2027, 1,000 local mayors and councillors signed an open letter this week demanding a primary of the mainstream to unite the divided political centre.

In their open letter, the local officials stressed the urgency of forming a unified front. "We need a broad gathering of democrats, and a primary now stands out as the only chance to achieve it," they wrote. "The coming together begins with the primary. And time is running out.”

The local representatives join an expanding chorus advocating for a centre primary, which includes high-profile figures such as Justice Minister Gérald Darmanin, former prime minister Michel Barnier, and President Emmanuel Macron. Likewise, an increasing number of voter polls suggest that the public supports the primary proposal to thin the presidential field.

The push comes amid an unusually crowded political landscape, with 38 declared candidates already in the running for 2027. Although some may fail to collect enough official signatures to reach the ballot, the total is notably high compared to the 2022 election, when 12 candidates officially qualified. While candidates span a broad political spectrum, many cluster around the political ground of the centre-right, centre, and centre-left.

Current first-round polling shows far-right candidate Marine Le Pen leading with roughly 31 percent of the vote, followed by far-left candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon at around 19 percent. Trailing behind them are centre-right candidate Edouard Philippe on approximately 14 percent, centre-left candidate Raphaël Glucksmann at 13 percent, centrist Gabriel Attal at nine percent, and right-wing candidate Bruno Retailleau at eight percent. Polling for the final four varies more widely because pollsters frequently test scenarios where not all of them are running.

Under France's two-round voting system, only the top two vote-getters from the first round advance to the second-round runoff, where voters pick their favourite of the two. Based on current polling, the second round would feature a runoff between Le Pen and Mélenchon, whom mainstream figures label "les extrèmes" (the extremes). All current polls predict a comfortable victory for Le Pen in that scenario. Proponents of a primary want to ensure a mainstream, centrist politician is a choice in the second round instead.

To qualify for the presidential ballot under French law, a person must be aged 18 or over, a French citizen (though not necessarily from birth), and free from court-ordered election bans. Candidates must also gain 500 signatures of support (parrainage) from elected officials—such as MPs, Senators, or local mayors—by March 2027. Aside from signature rules, French law provides no legal mechanism to force candidates to withdraw, meaning any primary or field-thinning agreement can only ever be voluntary.

Aside from a formal primary, candidates can reach voluntary agreements between themselves to step down. Former Macronist prime ministers Edouard Philippe and Gabriel Attal reportedly maintain an informal agreement that whichever candidate is trailing in the polls around Christmas will withdraw and support the other. Philippe, who currently holds a narrow lead among mainstream candidates, has repeatedly ruled out taking part in a primary, arguing that voters should have a full choice of candidates and decide the outcome themselves.

Despite his stance, Philippe faces mounting pressure as media coverage ramps up and more fellow candidates back the primary idea. He previously suggested that candidates with "no chance" should voluntarily stand down by February to narrow the field.

Analyzing the primary concept, politics expert John Lichfield noted that those calling for a primary feel justified because the three or four candidates of the central political mainstream are currently all somewhat becalmed in the polls. Logically, assuming one candidate represented the central mainstream, adding all their figures together could yield up to 40 percent of the vote—easily enough to qualify for the second round and potentially even top the voting in the first round.

However, Lichfield doubts the process would work out that way. He explained that people on the centre-left are not willing to vote in the first round for a centre-right candidate. While voters in the second round are used to having to swallow what they really believe and vote for the lesser of two evils, they want to vote with their heart in the first round. Consequently, a primary may not necessarily solve the moderate candidates' current problem.

Lichfield added that Philippe's arguments highlight valid concerns, as a primary could lead to more confusion and make people believe the establishment is ganging up. Such a move could validate claims by Le Pen and Mélenchon that a single central establishment governs in the interests of elites rather than the public regardless of campaign promises. Calling a primary no magical solution, Lichfield concluded that the "primary of the opinion polls," which has become the norm in France in recent years, remains the only way to resolve the current muddle.

Photo: Collected